Whether there can be life after death for a fallen crypto exchange, like FTX, is a complicated question. While the exchange faces huge challenges, including massive losses, it continues to sell its assets. Including, now, its crypto derivatives exchange LedgerX.
The future can look bleak when a firm, whether a crypto exchange or a conglomerate, goes bankrupt. In the case of FTX, the exchange sells off assets to try to make back some of the money it lost. But does this mean there is life after death for FTX? The answer is not simple and depends on several factors.
First, it’s crucial to know what bankruptcy means. Bankruptcy is a status that may (depending on local laws) offer legal protections allowing a company to restructure debts or liquidate assets to pay off creditors. The proceedings can get started voluntarily, by a company, or involuntarily by creditors.
FTX in Deep Waters
In the case of FTX, the exchange filed for bankruptcy voluntarily. According to reports, FTX suffered massive losses last November due to bad trades. The losses were so severe that FTX could not meet its financial obligations, and the exchange had to file for bankruptcy.
Since then, FTX has been selling off its assets to recoup some losses. The exchange has reportedly sold its stake in the Miami Heat NBA team, as well as its stake in the esports organization TSM. FTX has also sold some crypto holdings, including Bitcoin and Ethereum.
So, does this mean there is life after death for FTX? It’s possible, but several factors will determine the exchange’s fate.
One is the extent of FTX’s losses. If they were too severe, the exchange may simply not be able to recover. In this case, FTX may have to liquidate all its assets – not some of them. It may close its doors for good.
Another issue is the willingness of creditors to work with FTX. If creditors are willing to work with the exchange to restructure its debts, FTX may be able to emerge from bankruptcy with a viable business model. However, if creditors are willing to work with FTX, the exchange may be able to restructure its debts and may have to liquidate its assets.
A third factor is the competitive landscape of the crypto exchange industry. If FTX can emerge from bankruptcy, it will compete with other well-established exchanges like Binance, Coinbase, and Kraken. FTX must differentiate itself from these competitors and offer a unique value proposition to attract customers.
Light at the End of the Tunnel?
Despite these challenges, there are reasons to be optimistic about FTX’s future. One is the exchange’s leadership change. Now, FTX is led by CEO John Ray III, a bankruptcy specialist brought in to manage the exchange’s bankruptcy proceedings. He has experience in bankruptcy law and has worked on several high-profile insolvencies.
On Tuesday, FTX’s CEO John Ray III announced plans to sell the crypto derivatives exchange LedgerX to Miami International Holdings for $50 million. LedgerX is a regulated cryptocurrency derivatives trading platform acquired by FTX in 2020. This sale could help FTX recoup some of its losses. By divesting itself of LedgerX, FTX can streamline its operations and concentrate on rebuilding.
FTX will seek US bankruptcy court approval for the sale at a May 4 hearing.
“We are pleased to reach this agreement with MIH, which is an example of our continuing efforts to monetize assets to deliver recoveries to stakeholders,” FTX CEO John Ray said in a statement.
Additionally, FTX recovered over $5 billion in cash and liquid crypto assets. It continues to sell assets as part of that effort. FTX recently agreed to sell its stake in Web3 startup Mysten Labs for $95 million. But LedgerX is under Commodities Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) regulation, and the CFTC has warned consumers about the risks of exchange-traded products.
Are Serious Risks Involved?
The Commodities Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) regulates derivatives trading in the United States. LedgerX, the crypto derivatives exchange under the defunct company, is subject to this regulation. The CFTC has issued stern warnings in the past about the risks of exchange-traded products, including crypto derivatives.
Crypto derivatives are complex financial instruments that allow traders to speculate on the price movements of cryptocurrencies. They can be highly volatile and carry a significant risk of loss. The CFTC has warned consumers to be cautious when investing in these products and to consider their risk tolerance before trading carefully.
It’s worth noting that LedgerX is a regulated exchange that operates under the oversight of the CFTC. This means the exchange is subject to strict regulatory requirements, including capital requirements, reporting requirements, and compliance with anti-money laundering (AML) and know-your-customer (KYC) laws. These regulations are intended to protect investors and ensure the integrity of the derivatives market.
Despite these regulatory safeguards, crypto derivatives trading remains a high-risk activity. Traders who engage in it should be aware of the risks and invest only funds they can afford to lose.
But the real elephant in the room here is that LedgerX was part of Sam Bankman-Fried’s Ponzi scheme. The reputational concerns are considerable indeed. Especially after Storybook Brawl did not survive its association with FTX.
What Will Be Different?
It’s tough to say what Miami International Holdings’ (MIH) long-term plans are for LedgerX, as it has not made many public statements. But Miami International Holdings owns the Bermuda Stock Exchange and has a strong presence in Bermuda, where U.S. crypto ventures are relocating amid the SEC’s crackdown.
Given MIH’s bent, it may see LedgerX as a highly valuable asset in the growing crypto industry.
In recent years, Bermuda has become an increasingly popular destination for crypto ventures, as the country has established a regulatory framework friendly to blockchain-based businesses. In addition to owning the Bermuda Stock Exchange, MIH also operates the MIAX Options exchanges, regulated by the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). This suggests that MIH has experience working in regulated environments. Even that it is well-positioned to navigate the complex regulatory landscape of the crypto industry.
At the same time, Miami International Holdings (MIH) is a global exchange holding company that operates and owns several exchanges. Including the MIAX Options Exchange and the MIAX Pearl Equities Exchange. MIH’s experience and expertise in operating traditional financial exchanges may give it an edge in managing a crypto exchange.
MIH has experience developing and implementing trading technology, risk management systems, and compliance frameworks. All of which are critical parts of a successful exchange. Additionally, MIH has a track record in managing multiple exchanges. Which suggests it has the operational expertise to launch and grow a new crypto exchange.
In a June 8, 2022, tweet, MIAX Exchange Group shared its formation of a joint alliance with Lukka for the development of a suite of proprietary crypto derivatives. The products would trade on MIH exchange platforms, using Lukka-sourced crypto data.
As MIH acquires LedgerX, it may seek to leverage its expertise to expand the exchange’s offerings and grow its user base. It may also explore opportunities to integrate LedgerX with other MIH-owned platforms or use the exchange as a launching pad for new crypto ventures.
Setting the Foundation (Again)
Overall, the development has induced mixed emotions regarding FTX and its users’ fate. Some don’t see a future in the exchange or a potential FTX rebound. On the other hand, some law firms do big business in crypto firm restructurings.
Norton Rose Fulbright, a British-American multinational law firm, makes this a selling point. The theme here is that a strategic plan can point the way forward, and things are never hopeless.
Restructuring in the context of a crypto firm can refer to myriad things. Such as mergers, acquisitions, divestitures, and spin-offs. Multiple factors can drive these changes, including market conditions, financial performance, regulatory changes, or strategic priorities.
Crypto experts say that the rapid pace of innovation and disruption can make it tough for firms to stay competitive. Hence, restructuring is a way to realign the company’s focus and resources. Even to shed non-core assets and increase efficiency.
However, others warn that restructuring can have negative consequences. Such as job losses, cultural disruptions, and loss of talent. Additionally, the decentralized nature of the crypto industry can make it hard to predict the impact of restructuring on stakeholders. Including investors, customers, and partners.
Trusted
Disclaimer
Following the Trust Project guidelines, this feature article presents opinions and perspectives from industry experts or individuals. BeInCrypto is dedicated to transparent reporting, but the views expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect those of BeInCrypto or its staff. Readers should verify information independently and consult with a professional before making decisions based on this content. Please note that our Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Disclaimers have been updated.
